Skip to Content

Our 6 Favorite Half Caff K-Cups for Keurig Style Machines

Our 6 Favorite Half Caff K-Cups for Keurig Style Machines

There are lots of different reasons why you might want to stock some half caff k-cup coffee in your pantry. Maybe you are overly sensitive to caffeine, maybe you are trying to consume less caffeine, maybe you are saving your low caffeine coffee for the afternoons or evening.

Whatever the reason though there are more half-caff options now than ever before and I think they taste a lot better than mixing regular coffee with decaf… you know you’ve done that before, probably more than once too!

At A Glance: Our Top 5 Picks for Half Caff K-Cups

In the list below you’ll find some partially caffeinated k-cups from the Keurig brand, and many other non-Keurig brands including my favorite in this list Maud’s.

I’m a big fan of smaller brands, craft brands if you excuse the reference to the craft brew scene!

Maud’s claims their’s is the best half-caff coffee in the world, I’m not sure about that but it is the best I’ve ever tried and I’ve used their coffee twice before when weening myself off of caffeine before undergoing surgery. That’s a long story but needless to say I didn’t want to deal with caffeine withdrawals while recovering.

In any event all of the brands on this list are good at what they do so give them all a look and buy based on your own values.

  • Great for people on a budget
  • Medium roast
  • Trans fat, kosher and gluten free
VIEW ON AMAZON →See Customer Reviews
  • Medium roast
  • 50/50 mixture of dark roast regular and medium roast decaf
  • Smooth and very drinkable
VIEW ON AMAZON →See Customer Reviews
  • Medium roast
  • 100% arabica coffee
  • Rainforest alliance certified
VIEW ON AMAZON →See Customer Reviews
  • Rich body and honey-nut flavors
  • 50/50 blend of colombian supremo and colombian swiss water decaf
  • All fresh roasted coffee
VIEW ON AMAZON →See Customer Reviews
  • 36 count - folgers half caff coffee k-cups
  • Includes 2 boxes, 18 k-cups per box
  • All the flavor, half the caffeine
VIEW ON AMAZON →See Customer Reviews
  • Bright and flavorful
  • Compatible with any Keurig 1.0 or 2.0 brewer
  • USDA certified
VIEW ON AMAZON →See Customer Reviews

I’ll be providing short reviews of all the K-Cup coffees below in no particular order:

My Reviews of The Best Half Caff K-Cups

Many of the larger brands below can probably be found in your local grocery store but some of the smaller specialty brands I’ve never seen sold anywhere other than Amazon. Each link below points to the largest size sold on Amazon as this is typically the best per cup value.

Green Mountain Coffee Medium Roast K-Cup for Keurig Brewers, Half-Caff Coffee (Pack of 96)Green Mountain Coffee Medium Roast K-Cup for Keurig Brewers, Half-Caff Coffee (Pack of 96)

Green Mountain has a few different half-caff k-cups listed for sale but they are all basically the same medium roast coffee packaged in k-cups that look slightly different.

The differences have to do with the batch and production facility and not the flavor profile.

I like these because they are economical and taste good enough for me. They’re not my favorite but then again I’m picky and I tend to like lighter, more acidic roasts.

This coffee will be great for people on a budget, who like medium roast coffees, and who like to buy in bulk.

Check pricing out on Amazon here.

Maud’s Gourmet Coffee Pods - World's Best Half Caff, 100-Count Single Serve Coffee PodsMaud’s Gourmet Coffee Pods – World’s Best Half Caff, 100-Count Single Serve Coffee Pods

This k-cup is labeled as a Medium roast but it’s actually a 50/50 mixture of dark roast regular and medium roast decaf. The result is something a little darker than medium, smooth and very drinkable.

Because the regular in the blend is a top quality coffee the entire cup made from these k-cups really doesn’t have any of that decaf taste that so many people can pick up on.

These pods are made by a small batch micro-roastry in San Diego and if you care about this all coffee used in these K-Cups are organic and fair trade.

Older batches of these k-cups were made with some lids that didn’t stay on but recent offerings holdup better. I think these are the best k-cups on this list and recommend them to everyone.

Check pricing for Maud’s half-caff k-cups on Amazon here.

Skinnygirl Half Caff Coffees, Demi-caf, 24 CountSkinnygirl Half Caff Coffees, Demi-caf, 24 Count

Another excellent option in the low caffeine k-cup market.

Colombian SWP Half Caf Coffee Cups, 72 ct. of Single Serve Capsules for Keurig K-Cup BrewersColombian SWP Half Caf Coffee Cups, 72 ct. of Single Serve Capsules for Keurig K-Cup Brewers

This option is for those people who love Colombian coffee but want some caffeine but not a lot.

Folgers Half Caff Coffee K-Cups for Keurig K Cup Brewers and 2.0 BrewersFolgers Half Caff Coffee K-Cups for Keurig K Cup Brewers and 2.0 Brewers

This option was the surprise to me; I liked it a lot and it’s priced affordably coming from Folgers.

Half Caf Coffee Pod Variety Pack by Fresh Roasted Coffee, LLCHalf Caf Coffee Pod Variety Pack by Fresh Roasted Coffee, LLC

This is another smaller roasting company that makes their own blends. This will get the job done!

The Top Questions We See All The Time

Our customers routinely ask variations of these same questions when shopping for low caffeine k-cups and coffee grounds. Check below for anything that you may want clarification on.

  • How Much Caffeine is in a Half Caff K Cup – Every brand, roast, and flavor profile will contain more or less caffeine than others and individual brewing characteristics such as temperature and ratio of water to grinds will change the amount of caffeine in any cup but on average you’ll find that most half-caff k-cups brewed with roughly 8 ounces of water will contain roughly 50mg of caffeine. This is in comparison to 90-120mg in regular k-cup coffee and 10mg in decaf coffee. If you are weaning yourself off of too much caffeine then these k-cups will help you bridge the gap between full strength coffee and decaf without having to mix brewed or ground coffee yourself.
  • How Do They Make Half Caff Coffee? – When a coffee company makes decaf coffee they actually remove caffeine from the beans during production. With half-caff coffee however they literally mix fully caffeinated beans with decaf beans to produce something in between. For k-cups they will then grind and stuff those cups with the mixture. Basically when you mix beans or grounds at home you are making the same exact thing as half caff coffee. Buying it already mixed just makes things simpler for you. If you regularly buy standard brands of coffee then half caff coffee will be just fine for you but pre-made blends don’t typically get packaged with gourmet beans. If you really want the best coffee possible with the least caffeine possible then you will likely have to mix the beans yourself. Even still brands like Maud’s or Fresh Roasted Coffee, LLC offer excellent options that taste great and are super convenient.
  • Is Half Caff Coffee Good For You? – Half caff coffee in either ground or k-cup form is just as good for you as any other type of regular or decaf coffee. It is not made with instant coffee so you don’t have the health concerns that come with that. You still get all the antioxidants that come with regular coffee just a lot less caffeine.

If You Try a Few Different Half Caff Coffees You’ll Probably Find One You Like Better Than The Others

Lastly it’s worth stating the obvious.

If you buy small boxes of a few different brands you will probably find one variety that just tastes better to you than the others. It’s what I do all the time.

Personally I’m a big fan of Maud’s k-cups (Maud’s on Amazon here) when I want something low in caffeine but to my surprise I also like the Folgers varieties too and they have a few different options in a few different roast profiles. (Folger’s half-caff k-cups on Amazon here)

I also always recommend anyone looking for low caffeine coffees to consider some of the better decaf varieties out there too. Decaf coffee isn’t actually devoid of caffeine, there’s still a little bit in there.

If you are trying to ween yourself off of caffeine then it’s a nice step down from half caff to decaf before finally going cold turkey. I also just like keeping a box of decaf on hand for guests that come to dinner of myself when I get a coffee raving at 10pm!

We have a full review post for decaf k-cups here. Check it out if you found this post helpful

Please follow us because we are loving this new way to reach our customers!
Gamble Bay Coffee
FTC Disclaimer - This page may contain special links to merchants which can result in compensation paid to the site owner.